We’re posting this Complaint, not because it raises any new or novel issue, but because one of the plaintiff/property owners is San Francisco 49ers legend Joe Montana, who is suing San Francisco, alleging that the city’s maintenance of its stormwater/wastewater system (yes, the systems are one and the same) caused sewage to flood their
Property rights
Arizona Supreme Court To Decide Whether Condo Law Which Permits Association To Force Sale Of A Privately-Owned Unit Is A Taking
Here’s the Order by which the Arizona Supreme Court agreed to review a case we’ve been following.
The main issue is whether the Arizona condominium statute, which allows the condo association upon termination of the condominium regime, to sell individually-owned units is a taking under the Arizona Constitution.
Here are the questions presented:
FURTHER ORDERED:…
CA9: Property Owner Has Standing To Challenge Commercial Eviction Moratorium Under Contracts Clause
This is one of ours — argued by our Pacific Legal Foundation colleague Kady Valois — so we won’t be offering any commentary.
But we just have to post the U.S. Court of Appeals’ opinion in Iten v. County of Los Angeles, No. 22-55480 (Aug. 30, 2023), because it discusses two significant issues, and…
Register Now For The 20th Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference, Oct. 26-27, 2023
Early registration is a good thing because space is limited, especially at the Wren Building banquet on the 26th, at which the 2023 B-K Property Rights…
Our Drive-Time Conversation About Hawaii Inverse Condemnation And Wildfires
On this morning’s drive-time program, we joined KHVH’s Rick Hamada about whether Hawaii might adopt California’s version of inverse condemnation liability in wildfire cases. We also tried to clear up a few misconceptions (gad, I used “disinformation,” a term I try to eschew).
Here’s the program description:
Inverse Condemnation and Maui Wildfires: A Conversation with …
The Downside Of Seeking Injunctive Relief In Takings Cases
A fairly short one from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.
In Sheffield v. Buckingham, No. 22-40350 (July 31, 2023), the court affirmed the district court’s declining to issue a preliminary injunction enjoining State of Texas officials from enforcing the Open Beaches Act.
The presumptive public/private boundary on beaches in Texas…
Owners’ Counsel Toby Prince Brigham Scholarship – Applications Being Accepted
Two years ago, Owners’ Counsel of America endowed a scholarship in the name of its founder, property rights advocate and trial lawyer Toby Prince Brigham (1934-2021). The scholarship is for a second- or third- year law student to attend the annual three-day ALI-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation Conference (the upcoming Conference will be…
Still Time To Join Us Wed Aug 9: ALI-CLE’s “How Did Property Rights Fare at the Supreme Court? What Happened in the 2022 Term and What’s Next”
Tomorrow, Wednesday, August 9, 2023 at 1:00 – 2:00 p.m. (Eastern Time), please join us for ALI-CLE’s web program, “How Did Property Rights Fare at the Supreme Court? What Happened in the 2022 Term and What’s Next.”
Here’s the course description:
This has been a blockbuster U.S. Supreme Court term for property…
Recognizing A Property Rights Icon: “Mentors, A Path to Fairness, and the Joy of Taking”
We recently attended the American Bar Association’s Annual Meeting in Denver to speak at the Section of State and Local Government Law’s program, “The 100th Anniversary of Pennsylvania Coal v. Mahon: How the Takings Clause Became the Primary Check on Government Power When SCOTUS Abandoned Review Under the Due Process and Contracts Clauses …
What If The Hawaii Governor’s Cutting Of The Gordian Land Use/Environmental Knot Actually Works?
The two-plus years under the declared Co-19 emergency surely have given Hawaii’s executive-branch officials a clear vision of how much easier they could get their agendas accomplished without all that pesky democracy.
Hawaii’s Sweeping Emergency Management Act: Governor is the “Sole Judge”
Hawaii’s Emergency Management Act gives state and county executives broad and nearly unreviewable…




