North Dakota, as you might expect, can be cold in the winter. So cold that railroad switches need to be heated, else they get… frozen. The railroad uses refillable propane tanks, but these need to be refilled from time to time. And North Dakota is so cold in the winter that sometimes, the propane trucks
Property rights
Texas: Transportation Projects Exempt From Post-Kelo Limitations On Eminent Domain Power
Here’s one we’ve been waiting to drop. In KMS Retail Rowlett, LP v. City of Rowlett, No. 17-0850 (May 17, 2019), a deeply divided Texas Supreme Court held that a statute — adopted in response to Kelo — which seems to limit eminent domain power, also contains a massive hole: according to the court…
PruneYard Undone: California’s Union Easement – Which Invites Labor Organizers To Enter Private Property – Isn’t A Physical Taking
The title of this post may have you wondering, especially the part about how a regulation that invites others to physically enter private property, is determined by a court to not be a physical taking. (The court also hints at looking at a physical taking under Penn Central, and not by applying per se…
Tuesday Takings And Property Round-Up
Here’s what’s on the reading list for today:
- “Who owns the fertilized eggs? It’s a conundrum” from our Owners’ Counsel colleague Dwight Merriam, a piece about the property aspects of the question.
- “Dismissal of review in takings case restored precedential effect of Court of Appeal opinion” – the California Supreme
…
SCOTUS Reply Brief Clears Up Misconception About Eminent Domain Actions
Here’s the Reply Brief in a case which we’ve been following (and in which we filed this amici brief). This is the one in which landowners are challenging the district court’s issuance of an injunction in a Natural Gas Act taking which allow a private condemnor to obtain immediate possession of the land being…
New Article: Imperfect Takings
A law journal article worth reading (short, not too many distracting footnotes) on takings theory.
In Imperfect Takings, 46 Fordham Urban Law Journal 130 (2019), Professor Shai Stern writes about what he calls the “three safeguards” in eminent domain (due process, public use, and mandatory compensation), and how to evaluate the legality of takings…
California Inverse Condemnation And Wildfires: The Comic
Thanks to Professor Michael Wara’s Twitter feed, here is what might possibly be the first and only example of a comic strip devoted to inverse condemnation.
Yes, it is on an advocacy site (the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 1245), and it doesn’t really go into the details of the doctrine…
Links And Materials From Today’s Land Use Institute Sessions, Baltimore
Here are the links from today’s two sessions (the first, federal water issues impacting local land use; the second, Bringing and Defending a Takings Case):
- Maui groundwater CWA case
- the public trust along the Indiana shoreline
- tribal fishing rights and … highway culverts?
- WOTUS: son, they’re all my helicopters!
- Auer deference on the chopping
…
New SCOTUS Amici Brief In Pipeline Case: Courts Keep Using “Order of Condemnation.” We Do Not Think It Means What They Think It Means
Here’s the amici brief of the Owners’ Counsel of AmericaNew Jersey, Virginia, and West Virginia property owners; Cato Institute, and NFIB Small Business Legal Center which urges the Supreme Court to grant cert in a case we’ve been following for a while.
As regular readers understand, several federal courts of appeals …
The Ocean May Be Subject To The Public Trust, But Private Owners Own The Seaweed
We recommend you pick up the opinion of Maine’s Supreme Judicial Court in Ross v. Acadian Seaplants, Ltd., No. Was-17-142 (Mar. 28, 2019), because it deals with property rights in an area subject to the public trust. We think the court did a pretty good job of setting out the competing claims and…


