Austin, Texas, is where we’re at for the next few days, for the 2016 edition of the American Law Institute-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation conference, now in its 33d year. First time we’re in Austin, however, and our registration numbers are looking very good, and we haven’t had this big a turnout in years.
Attorneys Fees & Costs
Cal App: Intentionally Flooding Land To Protect The Environment Is A Physical Taking
A longer one from the California Court of Appeal, but unfortunately, we don’t have the time to digest it in detail. But you really should read Pacific Shores Property Onwers Ass’n v. Dep’t of Fish and Wildlife, No. C070301 (Jan. 20, 2016), in which the court upheld a ruling that the Department of Fish…
Fed Circuit On Rails-To-Trails Class Action Attorneys Fees, The Uniform Relocation Act, And A Possible Circuit Split
After the usual preliminaries — certification of a 253-member class, subclass certifications, discovery, and motions and cross-motions for summary judgment — the parties in a rails-to-trails takings case in the Court of Federal Claims mediated the dispute and ended up agreeing to $110 million plus interest as just comp for the property taken, and slightly…
Arkansas: Eminent Domain Fee Shifting Statute Only Applies To State Condemnations, Not City, Even Though State DOT Initiated The Taking
Another short one, this time from the Arkansas Supreme Court.
In City of Siloam Springs v. La-De LLC, No. CV-15-194 (Ark. Nov. 19, 2015), the court concluded that an Arkansas statute which requires the state to pay reasonable attorneys’ fees if the just compensation exceeds the deposit by more than 10%, does not apply…
Florida: When Govt Excessively Litigates An Eminent Domain Case, “Full Compensation” Requires Payment Of Attorneys Fees
Those of you who represent property owners on the business end of eminent domain who practice in Florida and the few other states which allow recovery of attorneys’ fees, consider yourselves lucky: the rest of us poor slobs who practice in places where they are not permitted — either as a component of a constitutional…
Fla App: Offer Early, Offer Often – Early Precondemnation Offer Does Not Trigger Attorneys’ Fee Statute
In General Commercial Properties, Inc. v. Florida Dep’t of Transportation, No. 4D14-0699 (Fla. Dist. App. Oct. 14, 2015), the court held that a statute which requires the trial court to use the “first written offer” by the condemnor made prior to the initiation of the eminent domain case as the benchmark when it is…
A Trial Judge Who “Gets” Eminent Domain
We don’t often post trial court decisions, but this recent ruling from an Idaho trial court awarding a property owner approximately $400,000 in fees and costs was a good read, and we’d like to share it with you all.
This is a ruling issued after a trial to determine just compensation for the partial taking …
Cal App: Condemnor’s “Final” Pretrial Offer, Contingent On Approvals From Other Agencies, Isn’t Really Final, Is It?
California law requires a condemnor to present to the property owner a final pre-trial settlement offer 20 days before trial, and for the property owner to make a final demand. If a court later determines that the condemnor’s final offer was unreasonable and the property owner’s final demand was reasonable, the property owner is entitled…
Final Chapter In Judicial Selection Commission List Public Records Case
As the Star-Advertiser reports here (“State pays newspaper for nominees battle“), Hawaii Governor David Ige has signed a bill which appropriates funds for the State to pay a portion of the legal fees and costs incurred by the Star-Advertiser during its lawsuit which compelled former Governor Neil Abercrombie to stop keeping secret the…
Cal App On Attorneys’ Fees In Eminent Domain
We were all ready to write up the California Court of Appeal’s latest opinion about our favorite subtopic — the recovery of attorneys’ fees in eminent domain actions — when our colleagues at the California Eminent Domain Report beat us to it (“Court Clarifies Rules for Recovery of Attorneys’ Fees in Eminent Domain Actions…

