We continue our series on the 100th anniversary of the mother lode of takings case, Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mahon, 260 U.S. 393 (Dec. 11, 1922), with this short essay recently published in the “Notice & Comment” feature of the Yale Journal on Regulation.
Robert H. Thomas
From The Mahon Property: Your Invitiation To The 40th ALI-CLE Eminent Domain Conference, Austin (Feb 1-4)
Neither snow nor …
Details, including registration here. Or download the print brochure.
In the recent past, we’ve sold out, so don’t miss out. We recently opened up a new room block, so there’s still time.
Come, join your colleagues for 3+ days of the best eminent domain and related programming. And, of…
NY Appellate Division: A Hospital Parking Lot Isn’t An Authorized Reason To Take
Unsurprisingly there isn’t a lot there in the majority opinion in Bowers Dev. LLC v. Oneida Cnty. Indus, Dev. Agency, No. 2022-00744 (Dec. 23, 2022) (this is from the New York courts after all, which don’t seem to write long opinions), but we’re posting it so you can compare the majority with the dissent. …
Wyoming: When You Settle An Eminent Domain Fight By Waiving All Future Claims, You Can’t Take Advantage Of A Reclaim Statute
Here’s one that’s holding over from 2022, but we wanted to make sure to post because it’s a good reminder that when you settle a case, you settle the case.
Wyoming is one of those jurisdictions that has one of those “I want it back” provisions, where if property is not actually used for X…
Md App: If You Want To Overturn The Amortization Doctrine, Take It Upstairs
You know the “amortization” doctrine: when an existing legal use is declared illegal, the government can avoid a takings claim by slowly phasing out the use, supposedly to allow the owner to recoup investment. The doctrine is established in Maryland by Grant v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore, 129 A.2d 363 (Md.
Ohio: Necessity Is Judged By The Property Taken, Not The Overall Project
Thanks to a colleague giving us a heads-up, we’re starting 2023 with a neat case.
In Ohio Power Co. v. Burns, No. 2021-1168 (Dec. 29, 2022), the Ohio Supreme Court declined to apply a statutory presumption of necessity to the power company’s efforts to use eminent domain to expand the scope of several existing…
The Good The Bad And The Ugly: There’s Something For Everyone In This Florida Takings Opinion
Here’s the latest from a case we’ve featured here before.
There’s something for everyone in the Florida District Court of Appeal (Second District)’s opinion in Jamieson v. Town of Fort Myers Beach, No. 2D21-2722 (Dec. 29, 2022).
Let’s start with the outcome: the court reversed the trial court’s summary judgment in a wetlands…
North Dakota: State May Lease Out Property It Doesn’t Own As Long As It Calls It “Overinclusive Leasing Activity”
We’ve had the North Dakota Supreme Court’s opinion in Wilkinson v. Bd. of Univ. & School Lands, No. 20220037 (Nov. 10, 2022), in our queue for a while because it isn’t exactly the clearest opinion we’ve come across. It is relatively short, so that’s not the issue. But it is cryptic and poorly written…
New Article: “Before Property: A Prehistory of Property Rights in Land”
We can’t claim to fully understand it (it’s full of words and phrases that frighten and confuse us), but we nonetheless commend to you a recent piece by lawprof Amanda Byer (University College Dublin), “Before Property: A Prehistory of Property Rights in Land.”
Here’s the Abstract:
This paper traces the origins of land…
You Can’t Just Say “Redevelopment” – Take Now, Decide Later Isn’t A Public Use
A classically short opinion from the New York Supreme Court (Appellate Division, Fourth District) in HBC Victor LLC v. Town of Victor, No. 683 (Dec. 23, 2022). (So short that we were tempted to simply post the opinion and let you read it, because it will probably take you just as long to read…



