Here’s the amici brief we’re filing today on behalf of the Owners’ Counsel of America, New Jersey property owners subject to natural gas pipeline takings, the Institute for Justice, and the Cato Institute, in support of a cert petition which is challenging the federal courts of appeals which have upheld giving prejudgment possession of property
Judicial Takings
Fed Cir: Inter Partes Reexamination Of Patents Isn’t A Taking
Usually, when we’re scanning the daily email from the Federal Circuit for takings decisions of interest, we look for “United States” as the defendant, and our eyes glaze over the other cases on the court’s docket such as patent matters. But today, we were rewarded: a takings issue in a patent matter.
In Celgene Corp. …
New Cert Petition: Private Pipeline’s Preliminary Injunction In Natural Gas Act Taking Created New Substantive Rights
Here’s the latest cert petition about an issue we’ve been following closely. Givens v. Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC, No. ___ (July 3, 2019)
As regular readers understand, several federal courts of appeals recently have upheld giving prejudgment possession of property to a private pipeline condemnor once a district has ruled in favor of the …
It Isn’t A Judicial Taking When A Family Court Orders Equitable Distribution Of Assets
Here’s a question. Domestic partnership hit the skids, ended up in Family Court. That court did what family courts do and divided up the couple’s assets. The partners were not married, so one of the issues was whether they were in a “committed intimate relationship.” Family court held no. Decision appealed, and eventually sent back to…
Knick Analysis, Part IV: Why Not Let Sleeping Dogs Lie? The Dissent And Stare Decisis
This is the fourth in our series of five posts with thoughts on the landmark decision in Knick. In this installment, the dissent. Related posts:
- Part I: After More Than 30 Years, Supreme Court Reopens The Federal Courthouse Door To Property Owners
- Part II: The Court Finds A Vehicle In A Zombie-Zoning Case
- Part III:
…
Mark Your Calendars: Federalist Society Teleforum On Preliminary Injunctions In Natural Gas Act Takings: Is “Take Now, Pay Later” Unconstitutional? (Friday, June 21, 2019)
The details are yet to be posted on the web, but mark your calendars now for an upcoming (two weeks from today, on Friday, June 21, 2019) Federalist Society teleforum, produced by the Environmental and Property Rights Practice Group, about an issue that we’ve been following that is the subject of at least three…
Shaka, When The Walls Fell: Yes, Knick Will Be About Takings, But It Will Be More About Federalism
With the opinion in the Knick v. Township of Scott case to drop as soon as Tuesday (we’re guessing the opinion will be by Chief Justice Roberts, by the way), hold on: we’re about to get super nerdy here. Impossibly nerdy. Yes, we’re revisiting the Star Trek analogies. We’ve been down this road before…
PruneYard Undone: California’s Union Easement – Which Invites Labor Organizers To Enter Private Property – Isn’t A Physical Taking
The title of this post may have you wondering, especially the part about how a regulation that invites others to physically enter private property, is determined by a court to not be a physical taking. (The court also hints at looking at a physical taking under Penn Central, and not by applying per se…
Materials And Links From Today’s Austin Eminent Domain CLE
Great crowd today in Austin for CLE International’s Eminent Domain seminar, co-chaired by our colleagues Chris Clough, Sejin Brooks, and Christopher Oddo. We spoke about “National Trends and Developing Issues in Eminent Domain.”
Here are the cases I referred to which are not included in your written materials:
…
Shaka, When The Walls Fell: Knick Is Going To Be About Federalism, Not Takings
With the opinion in the Knick v. Township of Scott case to drop as soon as Tuesday (we’re guessing the opinion will be by Chief Justice Roberts, by the way), hold on. We’re about to get super nerdy here. Impossibly nerdy. Yes, we’re revisiting the Star Trek analogies. We’ve been down this road before…


