property rights

Here’s a typically short one from New York. In Red Hook Boat Club, Inc.v. Town Board of Red Hook, No. 2025-09981 (N.Y. App. Div. Oct. 21, 2026), a New York intermediate appellate court upheld the Town’s exercise of eminent domain to take a boat club’s private property to turn it into a public riverfront park.
Continue Reading Conceivable Basis Strikes Again: Taking For Just About Anything Is Fine In New York

Here’s the cert petition we just filed asking the U.S. Supreme Court to review a Fourth Circuit decision (which we posted about in “CA4 Puts The Cart Before The Horse: Private Entity Doesn’t Have The Power Of Eminent Domain, But It Is Likely To Get It If Only Those Pesky Owners Were Stopped From Exercising Their Right To Exclude“).
Continue Reading New Cert Petition (Ours): Can Preliminary Injunctions Convey Eminent Domain Powers When There’s Been No Delegation Of Eminent Domain?

Is this a mural? Or is it a sign? (It matters because Salina, Kansas regulates signs but not murals.) And does a hamburger painted on the wall transform an unregulated mural into a regulated sign merely because the building is used to sell hamburgers?
Those were among the questions in Cozy Inn, Inc. v. City of Salina, No. 25-3225 (10th Cir. Oct. 30, 2026), where the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed entry of summary judgment against Salina, concluding that the city’s sign code failed even intermediate scrutiny.
Continue Reading CA10 Doesn’t See The Sign: A “Burger-esque” Mural On A Burger Joint Is A Nothingburger

In Barron v. United States, No. 2025-1179 (Oct. 22, 2026), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the Court of Federal Claims’ rejection of property owners’ takings claims arising out of the conversion of a 7.68-mile stretch of a former rail line in Florida to recreational trail use.
Continue Reading Really CAFED, “Right of Way” Means Fee Simple Absolute?

Here’s one worth reading. In GRE Downtowner LLC v. City of Seattle, No. 87886-7-I (Wash. App. Oct. 26, 2026), the Washington Court of Appeals reversed a Rule 12(b)(6) dismissal of a property owner’s regulatory takings claims arising from the combined effects of several Seattle rental-housing ordinances.
Continue Reading Owner Plausibly Alleged Seattle’s Rental Regulations Are Penn Central And Physical Takings

If you’ve ever wondered where the odd, backwards syntax of the Takings/Just Compensation Clause of the Fifth Amendment comes from, look no further than this highlighted provision in the original 1215 Magna Carta. Written in medieval Latin (natch), the sentence structure is not the same as English (modern or Old).
Continue Reading Magna Carta Pilgrimage, Part Duo

On a day earlier this week in which a different practice group in our firm Pacific Legal Foundation (incidentally led by a Property Rights lawyer, Chris Kieser, by the way) saw the U.S. Supreme Court agree to review a very important case, we also saw the Court deny certiorari in two takings cases we were watching.
Continue Reading SCOTUS Denies Two Takings Petitions, But Leaves Tantalizing Clues

We got underway today for the two-day Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference, now in its 23d year. Produced and sponsored by the William and Mary Law School and Queen Mary University of London, the conference focuses on (naturally) property rights, and is expressly designed to put property scholars in the same room as property practitioners.
Continue Reading Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference, London: Honouring The Work Of Professor James Penner

We’re in England for the upcoming Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference, and instead of heading directly to London from Heathrow, thought it would be a good time to take a short diversion to nearby Runnymede for what must be the O.G. Property Rights Pilgrimage (those visits we do from time to time to the actual sites of well-known cases).
Continue Reading Property Rights Pilgrimage, Runnymede Edition