Here’s the Verified Petition and Complaint, filed last week, in which a coalition of New York landowners sued the governor, claiming that the state is dragging its heels in its environmental review of fracking. We’re interested because a bad on fracking may lead to takings problems, although this lawsuit does not raise such
Environmental law
HAWSCT: Damage To Unique Property Subject To Unique Rules
There’s not much doubt that the now-notorious large-scale unpermitted upland grading and grubbing by a Kauai property owner on its private land caused the runoff that catastrophically damaged the adjacent beach and the reef offshore. The damage was pretty bad, and resulted in the “largest storm water settlement [with the federal EPA] in the United…
HAWSCT: State Agency Must Consider “Historical Evidence” Of “The Upper Reaches Of The Wash Of The Waves” When Certifying Shorelines
Today, the Hawaii Supreme Court issued an option in Diamond v. Dobbin, No. SCWC-30573 (Jan. 27, 2014), a case about shoreline certifications that we’ve been following.
It’s a beach case, obviously, but not about ownership. Shoreline certifications approved by the State Department of Land and Natural Resources are used as the baseline from which…
New Eminent Domain (And Related) Law Blog
One of the perks of attending the annual ALI-CLE Eminent Domain and Land Valuation conference (this year in New Orleans) is that in addition to 2 1/2 days of high-level CLE programming involving our favorite topic, you get to meet colleagues from across the nation (and internationally – expropriation lawyers from Canada were also with…
Coy Koontz, Prevailing Property Owner In SCOTUS Victory, Interviewed
Coy Koontz, Jr., the prevailing property owner in Koontz v. St. Johns Water Management District, No. 11-1147 (June 25, 2013) joined our Pacific Legal Foundation colleague Jim Burling for an interview on Fox and Friends.
Kudos to Jim and Mr. Koontz for getting down to the studio…
The Other Shoe Drops: Kauai Anti-GMO Ordinance Challenged In Federal Court
At the Hawaii Agriculture Law Conference which we just wrapped last week, perhaps the hottest topic on the agenda was the anti-GMO ordinances recently adopted by the Counties of Hawaii (Big Island) and Kauai.
Barista’s note: One advantage of having POTUS in town for a couple of weeks was that it resulted in a…
Upcoming HSBA Program: Administrative Appeals – How Do You Get There And How Do You Get Out Of There?
Next Monday, January 13, 2014, from noon to 1:00 p.m., I’ll be speaking — along with my Damon Key partner Greg Kugle — to the Hawaii State Bar’s Appellate Law Section about administrative appeals, in a session entitled “Administrative Appeals: How Do You Get There And How Do You Get Out Of There?” …
Links From Today’s Session On GMO Issues
Here are links to some of the materials mentioned at our session today on the GMO issue at the Hawaii Agriculture Law Conference:
- The Kauai ordinance, Bill 2491.
- The Kauai Mayor’s veto message, which included the privilege-waived memorandum of law detailing the legal problems with the measure.
- The County of Hawaii’s Big
…
HAWSCT: State Agency Approval Not A Ripeness Bar To Challenge To County Approvals
Here’s one for you land users which details how the very broad way Hawaii Supreme Court treats claims of jurisidictional ripeness.
In Blake v. County of Kauai Planning Comm’n, No. SCWC-11-0000342 (Dec. 19, 2013), the court held that a third-party challenge to the Kauai Planning Commission’s subidivision approval was ripe for adjudication, and that…
Hawaii Trial Court: Seawall No One Wants Belongs To State
Usually, in disputes about who owns oceanfront property (in Waikiki, the really nice part of Waikiki, down on the Diamond Head side), each party claims ownership. Beachfront property, after all, is pretty valuable.
But sometimes, it can be a liability.
So maybe “hot potato” is more accurate in this case, since it involves an old…




