What we’re reading today:
Here’s the video of today’s Ninth Circuit oral arguments in Drake’s Bay Oyster Co. v. Jewell, the case about an oyster farm in Marin County’s Point Reyes National Seashore, and Interior Secretary Ken Salazar’s decision to not renew its license. The Ninth Circuit has posted the briefs of the parties and amici here
oral Several justices (Justice Acoba, Justice Pollock) appeared quite hostile to the DLNR’s position. Their questions went beyond the usual “devil’s advocate” type questions where the questioner is testing a theory, or speaking through counsel to the other justices.
The Judiciary’s web site summarized the issues argued:
On January 11, 2008, Respondents Craig Dobbin and
In “Why big development is so difficult in Hawaii,” Hawaii Business magazine tackles an issue first raised by U. Hawaii lawprof David Callies in recently-published law review article (and follow-up interview), where he labeled the record of the 1993-2010 Hawaii Supreme Court on property issues “appalling” (80% overall success rate for environmental
William & Mary Law School, host of the annual Brigham-Kanner Property Rights Conference, has announced that Columbia Law School Professor Thomas W. Merrill will receive the 2013 B-K Prize at the conference (October 17-18, 2013, Williamsburg, Virginia). The photo above is of the plaque on the wall at the William & Mary Law School
Our state courts may be closed on this Good Friday, but the courts of most other states’ are not, Texas courts included. So here’s an opinion issued today by the Texas Supreme Court, El Dorado Land Co. v. City of McKinney, No. 11-0834 (Mar. 29, 2013).
[Update: more on the case here
If this article — Christie tells beachfront owners to sign easement for dunes or face ridicule — accurately relays the entire context of the situation, then something is seriously off here.
The article quotes New Jersey Governor Chris Christie as declaring that if shoreline property owners do not voluntarily surrender easements and allow the construction
Undercutting the trope that the lawsuit by a Marin County, California oyster farm to keep operating is all a right-wing plot (see also this story), famed Berkeley chef and food guru Alice Waters has asked the Ninth Circuit to file an amicus brief in support of Drakes Bay Oyster Company in its appeal of
In a recently-published law review article, U. Hawaii lawprof David Callies found that “the Moon Court [1993-2010] decided some of thestate’s most important property and related environmental and Native Hawaiianrights cases in favor of the various non-governmental organizations bringingthem (Sierra Club, Earthjustice, Hawaii’s Thousand Friends, and the NativeHawaiian Legal Corporation) approximately eighty-two percent of
The oral argument calendar of the Hawaii Supreme Court looks pretty interesting: