December 2009

This just in: the Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals has issued an opinion in Maunalua Bay Beach Ohana 28 v. State of Hawaii, No. 28175, a case we recently analyzed here.

We conclude that (1) Plaintiffs and the class they represent had no vested property rights to future accretions to their oceanfront land

Here’s one for all you CEQA mavens.

The California Supreme Court has determined that a denial of a conditional use permit to operate a private airport south of Sacramento is not a “project” under the California Environmental Quality Act. Sunset Sky Ranch Pilots Ass’n v. County of Sacramento, No. S165861 (Dec. 28, 2009).

Elk

The holiday brings “light blogging” as they say, so instead of a substantive post, we’re listing some of our favorite quotations about property rights, eminent domain, and the like.

Have any of your own? Send them, and I’ll post.


Such difficulties indicate that the dichotomy between personal liberties and property rights is a false one.

Yet another year has comeand gone — our blog’s fourth — so it’s time for ourannual summary of the past year’s highlights in land use law and other topics we cover.

Like 2008, it was mostly a year of infill and incrementaldoctrinal shifts, with a couple of sea changes thrown in forexcitement: the Ninth Circuit

Forthose of you stuck in the office today, our annual Christmas Eve contest: I’ll send to thefirst three people who email me today their very own “limited edition”of my firm’s extra-large, cobalt blue coffee mug, shownbelow.

(Don’t forget to include your name and postal address in your email.)

A happy and safe holiday to all.

WavesWith all that has been going on lately (SCOTUS arguments in the judicial takings case, New York’s courts issuing two big eminent domain decisions, etc.), we haven’t had the opportunity to summarize the oral argument in a very important Hawaii case.

Last month, the Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals heard arguments in the

Today, the Hawaii Supreme Court filed this Order Granting and Accepting Application for Transfer (Dec. 21, 2009), in County of Hawaii v. C&J Coupe Family Ltd. P’ship, transferring the appeal from the Intermediate Court of Appeals. [Disclosure: my Damon Key colleagues and I represent the property owners in this case.]

This is the property