2007

In UFO Chuting of Hawaii, Inc. v. Smith, No 05-16545 (Nov. 28, 2007), the Ninth Circuit held:

We hold that UFO’s right to operate vessels under its federal maritime coasting licenses does not preempt Hawaii law prohibiting parasailing off the coast of Maui during limited portions of the year to protect mating humpback whales.

Thanks to both Patty Salkin’s Law of the Land blog and Gideon Kanner’s Gideon’s Trumpet, we’ve been alerted to a regulatory takings case from the Georgia Supreme Court that presents an unusual fact pattern.  In Mann v. Georgia Dep’t of Corrections, No. S07A1043 (Nov. 21, 2007), the court struck down as an illegal

The Federalist Society’s section on property rights and environmental law has posted audio (14mb mp3) (with video coming soon) of a recent debate held in Washington, D.C., about the state of Property Rights in the United States.  Two Ninth Circuit judges, Alex Kozinski and Stephen Reinhardt, anchored the debate.  Jim Burling of the Pacific

The Wall Street Journal details impact fee issues in “Rising Use of ‘Impact’ Fees Rankles New-Home Buyers,” with some truly horrific examples, including one couple whom a California city demanded pay a $240,000 fee to get building permits to construct a rural home valued at $500,000, and homeowners who were required to sign

Some takeaway points:

  • The definition of “shoreline” in the Coastal Zone Management Act –while it may be based on, and similar to the common law boundarybetween public and private property — does not define the location ofthe public beach. It is merely the baseline from which the shorelinesetback (the “no-build” zone on beachfront lots). The