Federal Circuit

Subscribe to Federal Circuit via RSS

In an earlier post (“CAFED: Like We Said Before, “Inevitably Recurring” Flooding Is A Taking“), we covered the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit’s recent opinion in Alban v. United States, No. 23-1363 (Dec. 22, 2025), which held that the failure of the Corps of Engineers to properly operate two dams which resulted in upstream flooding when Hurricane Harvey struck was a “permanent” taking.

In this post, we’ll cover the latter part of the opinion, which dealt with the just compensation aspects of the case (each party appealed a portion of the Court of Federal Claims’s damage award).

The first claim was that the CFC’s award of compensation for damage to structures and personal property was not compensable. The Federal Circuit clarified that had the government merely taken a flowage easement, its claim to not be liable for such damage might have had some merit.

Continue Reading CAFED: Where The Government Chooses To Not Condemn But Allows It To Happen, It “Bears The Risk” That The Property Taken Is More Than The Government Wants To Pay For

Here’s the latest in an issue we’ve been following.

In Alban v. United States, No. 23-1363 (Dec. 22, 2025), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the Court of Federal Claims’s judgment concluding that the failure of the Corps of Engineers to properly operate two dams, which resulted in upstream flooding when Hurricane Harvey struck was a “permanent” taking.

The dams were built nearly 100 years ago to reduce downstream flood risks. The reservoirs are usually dry, and fill up when it rains a certain amount. At the time of construction, the Corps considered acquiring property which would be inundated when the reservoirs filled up to a certain level, but ultimately decided to not do so. The Corps made the decision to acquire only the properties predicted to be flooded in smaller storms. The Corps understood that flooding of additional property was predicted in more…

Continue Reading CAFED: Like We Said Before, “Inevitably Recurring” Flooding Is A Taking