You’ve known for a while that Palm Springs, California, specifically the Renaissance Palm Springs Hotel (a resort facility, but right in town, so you will have many options for “off campus” activities like art museums, the aerial tram, golf, and whatever suits your fancy, and close-in to the Palm Springs Airport), is the venue
August 2018
Monkey Selfies And Takings Ripeness
A quick one today because we’re offline (more on that later). Pacific Legal Foundation (the folks who are representing the property owner in the pending case challenging the continuing viability of the Williamson County ripeness doctrine), has posted this entry on their blog, “This monkey got his day in court. Property owners still …
From The “Be Careful What You Wish For” Department: California May Take Beach Easement
According to this story (“California moves closer to taking public pathway from billionaire Vinod Khosla“) in the Santa Cruz Sentinel, the State of California is considering exercising eminent domain to take an easement for public access over his San Mateo County property to access Martins Beach.
This is the case that resulted…
Damnatio Memoriae Be Damned: “Feeling Unwelcome” By Old Deeds With Racially Restrictive Covenants Isn’t Enough For Article III Standing
Here’s a short but interesting one from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. It isn’t exactly about the usual topics we cover, but is interesting enough that we thought we would post it.
The case involves old deeds (dated between 1922 and 1957) in the Adams County, Ohio recorder’s office, which contain…
Ninth Circuit: New Trial Motion, Not Federal Lawsuit, Is Condemnee’s Only Chance To Show Suppressed Evidence Affected Compensation Award
Kearney had her property taken. The school district doing the taking said it wanted to put a septic system on the property, and so commissioned a percolation study. But then it decided that instead, it would connect to a sewer system. The state court jury believed neither side’s appraiser completely, rejecting both Kearney’s appraisal ($1.4…
New Office Sign And Hurricane Lane Programming Notes
While the rest of my Damon Key colleagues are back home hunkering down due to the hurricane threat (we’re all fine, thank you to those who have inquired and sent good wishes), I am 6 time zones east about to begin the semester at William & Mary Law School, where I am teaching a course…
Some Takings Musings From The Ninth Circuit: “Prudential” Williamson County Ripeness, Interest As Property, And Rooker-Feldman…Oh My!
There’s a lot to digest in the Ninth Circuit’s opinion in Fowler v. Guerin, No. 16-35052 (Aug. 16, 2018). (We’ve been following the case, but the court’s issuance of the opinion slipped by — our thanks to a colleague for pointing it out).
The plaintiffs filed a class action alleging that state officials failed…
Fla App: Takings Dog Still Doesn’t Hunt
Back in April, we posted the Florida District Court of Appeal’s opinion in a case where landowners sued the state fish and wildlife commission because “deer dog hunters and their dogs” who had hunting licenses trespassed on the plaintiffs’ lands. The court, over a single judge dissent, affirmed the dismissal of the takings claims, because…
Fed Circuit: Tribe’s Claim For Taking Its Water Rights Didn’t Allege Injury
Appeals from motions to dismiss can be very unsatisfying, even for the winner. Granted, from a doctrinal standpoint, they’re pretty good at clarifying the law. And from a practice standpoint, the courts’ opinions often help future lawyers and litigants figure out how to plead cases, and frame issues. And the party who wins the appeal…
Ordinance Banning Industrial Mineral Mining Not A Regulatory Taking – But What About Palazzolo?
Challenging an ordinance that the court characterizes as an “even-handed” zoning regulation, even if it outlaws an existing conditional use, is going to be a tough one for a plaintiff. In theory, it need not be, given the right conditions. But any zoning lawyer will tell you that it is tough to overcome most courts’…

