The Legal Information Institute at Cornell Law School has published its preview of Arkansas Game & Fish Comm'n v. United States, No. 11-597 (cert. granted Apr. 2, 2012), the takings case set to be argued on October 3, 2012.
Petitioner, the Arkansas Game and Fish Commission (the "Commission") sued Respondent, the United States, for a violation of the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment, which compels the government to compensate parties when the government physically seizes property. Specifically, the Commission argues that the United States Army Corps of Engineers (the "Corps") permanently destroyed trees in a bottomland hardwood forest in Arkansas by intermittently flooding the forest for six years. The United States asserts that the actions of the Corps did not constitute a taking because the Corps did not oust the Commission of possession of the forest, and only a continuous invasion qualifies as a physical taking. The Supreme Court’s decision in this case will determine whether a temporary invasion is a taking which will affect the meaning of the Takings Clause as it is used in future disputes concerning the destruction of property.
The Federal Circuit held that the flooding caused by the Corps was only temporary, and did not result in a compensable taking merely because it eventually stopped, and "at most created tort liablity." The dissenting judge concluded that temporary flooding was no different in kind than more permanent flooding that occurs in other inverse condemnation cases, and regularly results in awards of compensation. The Federal Circuit's opinion is here.
We filed an amicus brief in the case supporting the property owner/petitioner, which argues that as long as the water releases by the Corps "directly and substantially" resulted in damage to petitioner's property (recall that the G&F Commission is seeking compensation only for the loss of its trees), it's a taking for which just compensation is required.
The petitioner's merits brief is here.
The Supreme Court's docket report for the case is here.